In-depth interviews with successful entrepreneurs
Starter Story grew through multiple channels including Reddit, where reposting interviews in entrepreneurship subreddits helped attract readers and newsletter subscribers. The company also leveraged SEO by repackaging interview insights into search-optimized articles, significantly increasing monthly visitors. Word of mouth played a role, as featured founders shared their stories and recommended other entrepreneurs, creating a growth flywheel. Additionally, Starter Story expanded into video content by traveling to film business owners for its YouTube channel, which accelerated growth.
“We found a more reliable distribution channel: SEO. I realized that in order to grow this business, we needed more (and better) distribution (again). Reddit and Hacker News were not scalable channels of distribution for us as the novelty of our case studies had mostly worn off. So, we started loo...”
“Pat started investing heavily into optimizing content for search engines. He now gets 1.6 million people to his site….every month. A majority of which come from SEO. He created a course called Lean SEO that he built to teach others how to get the same traction he has with SEO.”
“Once the site had hundreds of case studies, Walls discovered a new opportunity. The interviews contained valuable data — but they weren’t optimized for search. So Starter Story began repackaging insights from its interviews into SEO-friendly articles. We went from a few thousand visitors per mont...”
“By the end of 2017, the site was getting around 30,000 monthly visitors, almost entirely from organic search.”
“hubspot should acquire starter story the SEO ship is sinking IMO hubspot needs to pivot wayyyy harder to video, specifically youtube i'm biased, but acquiring starter story would take their youtube game to the next level”
“Even in the first month of running Starter Story, with only five interviews conducted, Pat promoted his newsletter on his own Facebook, Instagram, and Reddit. His numbers? 27 newsletter subscribers and 1,200 sessions.”
“Starter Story was generating about $8,000 per month from a combination of newsletter sponsorships and a premium membership at $29 per month.”
“What worked: Don't want to bore you too much in this milestone, but I wrote a bit more about my journey, and also what worked, such as: Building an email list and announcing features constantly”
“By this point, Walls had added an intake form where people could apply to be interviewed on Starter Story. His early success on Reddit and social shares helped build the brand and brought more entrepreneurs in to be featured, creating a sort of flywheel effect.”
“After six months, I start thinking about monetization and how I can make my first dollar. I monetize the newsletter with a sponsorship, and I start making some money from affiliate revenue.”
“I realized I needed a distribution channel. I tried a lot of things and finally found something that worked: posting the case studies on reddit. My first success: This post hit the top of r/entrepreneur, and it validated that our case studies with founders were actually interesting and valuable t...”
“Starter Story’s early growth came not from search engines but from Reddit. Walls would repost the interviews — sometimes nearly in their entirety — inside entrepreneurship subreddits. At the end of each post, he included a link inviting readers to subscribe to the Starter Story newsletter.”
“After four months, I start working on marketing, and I get my first big break. One of my stories goes viral on Reddit, and thousands of people crash my site and join the newsletter.”
“One of Starter Story’s first big breaks came when Walls discovered the r/Entrepreneur forum on Reddit. The kinds of stories that were being shared on that subreddit were very similar to the case studies he published on Starter Story.”
“In the case of Starter Story, the main source of this initial traction was through Reddit. Although Pat had some initial success on Reddit, there were two main takeaways he found that made this month particularly successful, with over 15,000 views on one post alone.”
“I just went to all of the communities. I just went to all of my. Lines all of my friends that are using Shopify and ask them to install our app and try it for themselves. I made the app free and this way you can get more installs and of course more installs than convert to more reviews and of cou...”
“Every time we would do an interview with someone, we would ask them to recommend five other entrepreneurs. It created this little flywheel. Every founder featured on Starter Story would share the article with their own audience. That exposure drove more entrepreneurs to submit their own stories.”
“Traffic was anemic at first, but some of the founders he interviewed started sharing their case studies on their social media accounts.”
“Reminding myself that I’m not doing any paid advertising and the product is growing and customers are finding Pigeon through organic means (more on that later).”
“The next big bet was video. Instead of waiting for creators to come to him, Walls took Starter Story on the road, driving across the US to film raw, on-site stories with businesses for his YouTube channel, which surged past 100,000 subscribers in months. Today, his YouTube channel has roughly 778...”
“Five years in, Starter Story made a major push into YouTube, traveling the country to film business owners. The channel reached 100,000 subscribers in 6 months and accelerated growth.”
“He’s been doing building in public since before it was even called that, and it’s helped connect him with thought leaders and is almost a flywheel to get more founders for his interviews as well.”
“He also started building tools like a business idea generator and a business name generator, which became some of the highest-traffic pages on the site.”
“Starter Story was generating about $8,000 per month from a combination of newsletter sponsorships and a premium membership at $29 per month.”
“Pat has been using automation to run the business more effectively since the beginning. As a solo founder, he believes it’s important to automate as much as you can to free up your time. He built automations and templates to help run a massive content business.”
“I think around 95% of our reviews for for our apps come from customer support. Our customer support is, is top notch. All of our customer support agents are really techni...”
“What worked: Don't want to bore you too much in this milestone, but I wrote a bit more about my journey, and also what worked, such as: Quora”
“Alright, you gotta stop you real quick and zoom out. Erica has built an insane business, 4 million a year on top of the Shopify App Store without spending any money on ads. And that's maybe the secret. Building on top of a marketplace, you don't need a big audience, you don't need to spend money ...”
“Another distribution channel: Hacker News... People on HN seemed to love business success stories and learning how much money people made from online businesses. When you have a popular post, it can result in lots of high-quality traffic. Relevant entrepreneurs, media, etc pay attention to the site.”
“Pat personally conducted hundreds of interviews before automating any part of the process.”
“After six months, I start thinking about monetization and how I can make my first dollar. I monetize the newsletter with a sponsorship, and I start making some money from affiliate revenue.”
“What worked: Don't want to bore you too much in this milestone, but I wrote a bit more about my journey, and also what worked, such as: Direct sales”
“Pat is someone who experiments a lot with his website and newsletter. He seems to have a running list of things to try out all the time. Examples include adding a static table of contents and content upgrades to improve dwell time and conversion.”
“Over time, the company expanded beyond written founder interviews into video and community.”
“Even in the first month of running Starter Story, with only five interviews conducted, Pat promoted his newsletter on his own Facebook, Instagram, and Reddit.”